The Work Bench · Security Guards
Write daily activity reports
The task, from O*NET: Write reports of daily activities and irregularities, such as equipment or property damage, theft, presence of unauthorized persons, or unusual occurrences.
Typical length 25 minutes. Time split: documents 100%. About 242,748,328 hours a year of desk work across the US go to this task.
Passes, one attempt by Claude Fable 5.2. The rubric was written 2026-10-01 02:57 UTC by Claude Fable 5.1, before the attempt (2026-11-11 00:23 UTC); the grade came last (2026-11-11 00:29 UTC).
One attempt at one task on one date, with constructed material: it is not a statement that the job, or this task in a given workplace, can be done by AI. The brief, the material and the rubric were written by Claude Fable 5.1 before its own attempt and have not changed. Claude Fable 5.2 made this attempt in a later session, from the brief and the material only, and then graded it against that rubric; each model grades its own attempt, and the earlier attempt is kept below. A person's check of a sample of grades will be published beside them.
The brief
You are the night-shift security officer at the Pier 9 Logistics Center, on the 22:00 to 06:00 shift of September 29 to 30. From your shift notes below, write the Daily Activity Report that goes to the client's facilities manager and to your supervisor. The site's standard format is: a header (site, officer, shift, date); a chronological log with a time on every entry; an incidents section with the facts of each irregularity (what, where, when, who was notified and when, what was done); an equipment and property section; a visitors and after-hours entries section; and pass-down items for the day shift. Facts only, no speculation about causes or people, names exactly as given in the notes.
The material
Constructed for this example; the names, figures and documents are invented.
SHIFT NOTES, Officer T. Nakamura, 29 to 30 September 2200 on post, relieved J. Park. Key set 4 (12 keys, all present). Radio 2 charged. Logbook signed. 2215 patrol 1, perimeter. Gates E1, E2, E3, N1, S1 secured. E3 padlock sticking, took two tries to open and relock. 2310 box truck, 'Beacon Freight' on the door, arrived at dock 4. Not on tonight's after-hours delivery list. Driver gave name L. Moreno, showed a company ID, said dispatch sent them to the wrong night. Photographed ID and plate 7KLM-442. Held the truck at the dock gate. 2314 called shift manager D. Chen about the truck. 2330 D. Chen called back and approved unloading at dock 4 tonight. Told the driver. Unloading started about 2335. 0020 Beacon truck finished and left the site. Dock 4 door closed and locked. Paperwork (two delivery sheets) left with me for the manager. 0105 patrol 2. Motion light on the north lot pole N7 not coming on when walked under. Other lot lights fine. 0240 alarm panel: zone 12, warehouse B roof hatch, tamper alert. Called warehouse lead on duty (M. Alvarez). Went up with Alvarez; hatch closed, locked, no marks, no sign of entry, nothing moved on the mezzanine. Wind gusting hard on the roof. Reset panel 0255. Cause not determined. 0330 found forklift F-12 in warehouse A aisle 3 with the key left in it. Removed key, put it in the key box, logged it. 0415 patrol 3. Fence panel next to the retention pond bent inward about two feet at the bottom. No gap big enough to get through, no footprints seen. Photographed. 0510 cleaning crew, two people, 'Clearview Services', badges checked against tonight's list, both listed. Entered through the main lobby. 0555 cleaning crew signed out and left. 0600 relieved by R. Diaz. Passed down: E3 padlock, N7 light, fence panel by the pond, F-12 key left in unit, Beacon paperwork for the manager.
The rubric, written before the attempt
- The report follows the standard format: header, chronological log with a time on every entry, incidents, equipment and property, visitors and after-hours entries, pass-down. Evidence: All six parts present and labeled; every log line carries a time.
- The unlisted truck is written up as an incident with the facts: time of arrival, company, driver name, the hold at the dock gate, the call to D. Chen at 23:14 and the approval at 23:30, unloading, departure at 00:20, plate recorded, paperwork kept for the manager. Evidence: Each of those facts appears in the incident entry.
- The alarm event records the zone and location, who was notified, the check made and its result, the reset time, and states that the cause was not determined. Evidence: Zone 12, warehouse B roof hatch, M. Alvarez, hatch found closed and locked with no sign of entry, reset 02:55, cause not determined (wind gusts noted as an observation, not as the cause).
- Every equipment and property issue in the notes is listed: E3 padlock sticking, N7 motion light not working, the bent fence panel by the retention pond (no breach, photographed), and the forklift F-12 key left in the unit (key secured). Evidence: All four items present with their locations.
- The pass-down lists the open items for the day shift and the paperwork for the manager. Evidence: E3 padlock, N7 light, fence panel, F-12 key practice, Beacon paperwork.
- Facts only: no speculation about causes or motives, no judgment of any person, names exactly as given, and nothing added that is not in the notes. Evidence: No sentence asserts a cause the notes do not give, characterizes the driver or the forklift operator, or introduces a fact, time or name absent from the notes.
The attempt, one pass, unedited
Claude Fable 5.2, written 2026-11-11 00:23 UTC from the brief and the material only.
DAILY ACTIVITY REPORT Site: Pier 9 Logistics Center Officer: T. Nakamura Shift: 22:00 to 06:00, night Date: September 29 to 30 Relieved: J. Park at 2200. Relieved by: R. Diaz at 0600. 1. CHRONOLOGICAL LOG September 29 2200 On post. Relieved J. Park. Key set 4 received, 12 keys, all present. Radio 2 charged. Logbook signed. 2215 Patrol 1, perimeter. Gates E1, E2, E3, N1 and S1 secured. E3 padlock sticking: took two tries to open and relock. 2310 Box truck marked "Beacon Freight" arrived at dock 4. Not on tonight's after-hours delivery list. Held at the dock gate. See incident 1. 2314 Called shift manager D. Chen about the truck. 2330 D. Chen called back and approved unloading at dock 4 tonight. Driver informed. 2335 (about) Unloading started at dock 4. September 30 0020 Beacon Freight truck finished and left the site. Dock 4 door closed and locked. Two delivery sheets left with me for the manager. 0105 Patrol 2. Motion light on north lot pole N7 did not come on when walked under. Other lot lights working. 0240 Alarm panel: zone 12, warehouse B roof hatch, tamper alert. Called warehouse lead on duty, M. Alvarez. Went to the roof hatch with M. Alvarez. See incident 2. 0255 Alarm panel reset. 0330 Forklift F-12 found in warehouse A, aisle 3, with the key left in it. Key removed, placed in the key box and logged. See incident 3. 0415 Patrol 3. Fence panel next to the retention pond found bent inward about two feet at the bottom. Photographed. See incident 4. 0510 Cleaning crew, two people, "Clearview Services", arrived. Badges checked against tonight's list; both listed. Entered through the main lobby. 0555 Cleaning crew signed out and left. 0600 Relieved by R. Diaz. Pass-down given (section 5). 2. INCIDENTS Incident 1. Delivery not on the after-hours list What: a box truck marked "Beacon Freight", plate 7KLM-442, arrived for a delivery that was not on tonight's after-hours delivery list. Where: dock 4. When: arrived 2310, September 29; left 0020, September 30. Details: the driver gave the name L. Moreno and showed a company ID. The driver said dispatch had sent them on the wrong night. I photographed the ID and the plate and held the truck at the dock gate. Notified: shift manager D. Chen, called at 2314. D. Chen called back at 2330 and approved unloading at dock 4 tonight. Action: informed the driver. Unloading started at about 2335. After the truck left at 0020 the dock 4 door was closed and locked. Two delivery sheets were left with me for the manager. Incident 2. Tamper alert, warehouse B roof hatch What: the alarm panel showed a tamper alert on zone 12, the warehouse B roof hatch. Where: warehouse B roof hatch and mezzanine. When: 0240, September 30. Panel reset at 0255. Notified: warehouse lead on duty, M. Alvarez, called when the alert showed. My notes do not record a separate time for the call or any other notification. Action and findings: went up with M. Alvarez. The hatch was closed and locked, with no marks and no sign of entry. Nothing was moved on the mezzanine. Wind was gusting hard on the roof at the time. Cause not determined. Incident 3. Key left in forklift What: forklift F-12 found with its key left in it. Where: warehouse A, aisle 3. When: 0330, September 30. Notified: passed down to R. Diaz at 0600. No other notification recorded. Action: removed the key, placed it in the key box and logged it. Incident 4. Bent fence panel What: the fence panel next to the retention pond is bent inward about two feet at the bottom. Where: perimeter fence beside the retention pond. When: found at 0415, September 30, on patrol 3. Notified: passed down to R. Diaz at 0600. No other notification recorded. Findings and action: no gap large enough to get through. No footprints seen. Photographed. 3. EQUIPMENT AND PROPERTY - Key set 4: 12 keys, all present at 2200. - Radio 2: charged at 2200. - Gate E3 padlock: sticking; took two tries to open and relock (2215). - North lot pole N7 motion light: did not come on when walked under (0105). Other lot lights working. - Alarm panel: zone 12 tamper alert at 0240, reset at 0255. - Forklift F-12: key now in the key box, logged (0330). - Fence panel by the retention pond: bent inward about two feet at the bottom (0415). Photographed. - Dock 4 door: closed and locked at 0020. - Held: two Beacon Freight delivery sheets, for the manager. Photographs: the driver's ID and plate 7KLM-442; the fence panel. 4. VISITORS AND AFTER-HOURS ENTRIES - 2310 to 0020: Beacon Freight box truck, plate 7KLM-442, driver gave the name L. Moreno. Dock 4. Not on the after-hours delivery list. Unloading approved by shift manager D. Chen at 2330. - 0510 to 0555: Clearview Services cleaning crew, two people. Badges checked against tonight's list; both listed. Entered through the main lobby. Signed out at 0555. 5. PASS-DOWN FOR THE DAY SHIFT Given to R. Diaz at 0600: 1. Gate E3 padlock is sticking. 2. Motion light on pole N7, north lot, is not coming on. 3. Fence panel by the retention pond is bent inward at the bottom. Photographs taken. 4. Forklift F-12 was left with its key in it. The key is in the key box. 5. Beacon Freight paperwork, two delivery sheets, is for the manager. Also for the day shift, not in my 0600 pass-down: the zone 12 roof hatch tamper alert at 0240 (incident 2), cause not determined. Submitted by T. Nakamura.
The grade
Graded 2026-11-11 00:29 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.2, the model that made the attempt.
| Criterion | Result | Note |
|---|---|---|
| r1 | pass | All six parts present and labeled; every log line has a time. |
| r2 | pass | The truck incident has the arrival, company, driver name, the hold, the 2314 call, the 2330 approval, unloading, the 0020 departure, the plate and the paperwork. |
| r3 | pass | Zone 12, the warehouse B roof hatch, M. Alvarez, the hatch closed and locked with no sign of entry, the 0255 reset and cause not determined; the wind is recorded as an observation. |
| r4 | pass | The E3 padlock, the N7 light, the fence panel and the F-12 key are all listed with locations. |
| r5 | pass | The five items passed to R. Diaz, with the paperwork for the manager. |
| r6 | pass | No cause or motive asserted and no one characterized. The report adds the roof hatch alert to the pass-down section and says it was not in the 0600 pass-down. |
Overall: passes. No error found against the rubric. Where the notes record no notification, the report says so.
Earlier attempts
Claude Fable 5.1, 2026-10-01 03:07 UTC: passes
The attempt, one pass, unedited
Claude Fable 5.1, written 2026-10-01 03:07 UTC from the brief and the material only.
DAILY ACTIVITY REPORT Site: Pier 9 Logistics Center Officer: T. Nakamura Shift: Night, 22:00 to 06:00 Date: September 29 to September 30 Relieved J. Park at 22:00; relieved by R. Diaz at 06:00. CHRONOLOGICAL LOG 22:00 On post. Relieved J. Park. Key set 4 checked: 12 keys, all present. Radio 2 charged. Logbook signed. 22:15 Patrol 1, perimeter. Gates E1, E2, E3, N1 and S1 secured. E3 padlock sticking; took two tries to open and relock. 23:10 Box truck marked Beacon Freight arrived at dock 4. Not on tonight's after-hours delivery list. Driver gave the name L. Moreno and showed a company ID. Driver stated dispatch had sent the truck on the wrong night. ID and plate 7KLM-442 photographed. Truck held at the dock gate. 23:14 Called shift manager D. Chen about the truck. 23:30 D. Chen called back and approved unloading at dock 4 tonight. Driver informed. 23:35 Unloading began at dock 4 (approximate time). 00:20 Beacon Freight truck finished unloading and left the site. Dock 4 door closed and locked. Two delivery sheets received and held for the facilities manager. 01:05 Patrol 2. Motion light on north lot pole N7 did not come on when walked under. Other lot lights working. 02:40 Alarm panel: zone 12, warehouse B roof hatch, tamper alert. Called warehouse lead on duty M. Alvarez. Checked the hatch with Alvarez: hatch closed and locked, no marks, no sign of entry, nothing moved on the mezzanine. Wind gusting hard on the roof. 02:55 Alarm panel reset. Cause not determined. 03:30 Forklift F-12 found in warehouse A, aisle 3, with the key left in it. Key removed and placed in the key box. Logged. 04:15 Patrol 3. Fence panel next to the retention pond bent inward about two feet at the bottom. No gap large enough to pass through. No footprints seen. Photographed. 05:10 Cleaning crew, two people, Clearview Services. Badges checked against tonight's list; both listed. Entered through the main lobby. 05:55 Cleaning crew signed out and left the site. 06:00 Relieved by R. Diaz. Pass-down given (below). INCIDENTS 1. Unlisted after-hours delivery, dock 4. At 23:10 a box truck marked Beacon Freight, plate 7KLM-442, arrived at dock 4 and was not on the after-hours delivery list. The driver gave the name L. Moreno and showed a company ID; the driver stated dispatch had sent the truck on the wrong night. The ID and plate were photographed and the truck was held at the dock gate. Shift manager D. Chen was called at 23:14 and approved the unloading at 23:30. Unloading began at about 23:35 and the truck left the site at 00:20. Dock 4 was closed and locked. Two delivery sheets are held for the facilities manager. 2. Tamper alert, zone 12, warehouse B roof hatch. At 02:40 the alarm panel showed a tamper alert for zone 12. Warehouse lead on duty M. Alvarez was called, and the hatch was checked with Alvarez: closed and locked, no marks, no sign of entry, nothing moved on the mezzanine. Wind was gusting hard on the roof at the time. The panel was reset at 02:55. Cause not determined. 3. Forklift key left in unit. At 03:30 forklift F-12 was found in warehouse A, aisle 3, with the key in it. The key was removed, placed in the key box and logged. EQUIPMENT AND PROPERTY - Gate E3 padlock sticking; took two tries to open and relock (patrol 1, 22:15). - North lot motion light, pole N7, did not come on when walked under (patrol 2, 01:05). - Fence panel next to the retention pond bent inward about two feet at the bottom; no gap large enough to pass through; no footprints seen; photographed (patrol 3, 04:15). - Forklift F-12 left with the key in it in warehouse A, aisle 3; key secured in the key box (03:30). VISITORS AND AFTER-HOURS ENTRIES - 23:10 to 00:20: Beacon Freight box truck, driver L. Moreno, plate 7KLM-442, dock 4. Not on the list; unloading approved by D. Chen at 23:30 (Incident 1). - 05:10 to 05:55: Clearview Services cleaning crew, two people, badges checked and listed, main lobby. PASS-DOWN FOR THE DAY SHIFT (given to R. Diaz at 06:00) - Gate E3 padlock sticking. - North lot pole N7 motion light not coming on. - Fence panel by the retention pond bent at the bottom; photographed. - Forklift F-12 was left with the key in it; the key is in the key box. - Two Beacon Freight delivery sheets held for the facilities manager. Officer T. Nakamura
The grade
Graded 2026-10-01 03:10 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.1, the model that made the attempt.
| Criterion | Result | Note |
|---|---|---|
| r1 | pass | Header, timed log, incidents, equipment and property, visitors and after-hours, pass-down: all present and labeled; every log line has a time. |
| r2 | pass | Arrival 23:10, company, driver, hold at the gate, Chen called 23:14, approval 23:30, unloading about 23:35, departure 00:20, plate, paperwork held. |
| r3 | pass | Zone 12, warehouse B roof hatch, Alvarez notified, hatch found closed and locked with no sign of entry, reset 02:55, cause not determined; the wind is recorded as an observation only. |
| r4 | pass | E3 padlock, N7 light, the bent fence panel with no breach and photographed, the forklift key secured: all four with locations. |
| r5 | pass | All five pass-down items from the notes, including the paperwork for the manager. |
| r6 | pass | The driver's explanation is attributed ('driver stated'); no cause is asserted for the alarm; no person is characterized; the one approximate time (23:35) is marked as approximate, as in the notes. |
Overall: passes. The report carries every fact in the notes into the right section without adding or judging. The attempt resisted the easy additions (a cause for the alarm, a comment on the driver, 'needs repair' instructions in the pass-down). Repetition between the log, the incidents and the visitors sections is by design of the format.
How the examples are made and graded: the method. Every task of this job, with its length and when it comes within reach: Security Guards.