Skip to content
STRATUSWORKFORCE SCAN

The Work Bench · Sales Representatives of Services, Except Advertising, Insurance, Financial Services, and Travel

Monitor the market and competitors

The task, from O*NET: Monitor market conditions, innovations, and competitors' services, prices, and sales.

Typical length 50 minutes. Time split: documents 100%. About 191,391,809 hours a year of desk work across the US go to this task.

Passes, one attempt by Claude Fable 5.2. The rubric was written 2026-10-01 03:28 UTC by Claude Fable 5.1, before the attempt (2026-11-11 00:19 UTC); the grade came last (2026-11-11 00:29 UTC).

One attempt at one task on one date, with constructed material: it is not a statement that the job, or this task in a given workplace, can be done by AI. The brief, the material and the rubric were written by Claude Fable 5.1 before its own attempt and have not changed. Claude Fable 5.2 made this attempt in a later session, from the brief and the material only, and then graded it against that rubric; each model grades its own attempt, and the earlier attempt is kept below. A person's check of a sample of grades will be published beside them.

The brief

You sell commercial cleaning contracts for Keystone Facility Services in a mid-size metro. Your sales director wants a one-page market brief for Monday: what the three main competitors now offer and charge, what changed since last quarter, and what it means for the two proposals due next week, a 40,000 square foot office building and a 12,000 square foot medical clinic. Use only the material below. Put the implications as options for the director to choose among, not as instructions.

The material

Constructed for this example; the names, figures and documents are invented.

LAST QUARTER'S PRICE NOTES (July)
Keystone: office nightly cleaning $0.11 per square foot per month; medical $0.16.
Metro Shine: office $0.10; medical $0.15.
Brightpath Janitorial: office $0.12; no medical offering.
CleanWorks Co: office $0.095; medical $0.14; 12-month contracts with a 90-day exit.

CURRENT COMPETITOR INFORMATION (October)
Metro Shine rate card, October 1: office $0.105 per square foot per month on a 3-year contract, or $0.115 on a 1-year contract; medical $0.16; a 'green certified' program now included at no charge; day porter add-on $28 an hour.
Brightpath announcement, September 20: entering medical cleaning with a certified team, introductory $0.145 per square foot per month for the first year; office $0.12, unchanged; new electrostatic disinfection add-on at $0.02 per square foot per month.
CleanWorks Co website, September 28: office $0.10 (up from $0.095); medical $0.14; month-to-month now available at $0.11 office; '24-month price lock' on contracts.
News item, September 30: the regional minimum wage rises 6% on January 1.

CUSTOMER COMMENTS
Facilities manager at a current Keystone office client: 'Metro Shine pitched us at $0.105 with the green program. We stayed because your crew is reliable, but the gap is noticeable.'
The clinic prospect: 'We need documented disinfection protocols and proof of staff training. Price is second.'

The rubric, written before the attempt

  1. Each competitor's current position is stated correctly with the figures. Evidence: Metro Shine $0.105 three-year or $0.115 one-year office, $0.16 medical, green program free, porter $28 an hour; Brightpath medical at $0.145 introductory, office $0.12, electrostatic $0.02; CleanWorks office $0.10, medical $0.14, month-to-month $0.11, 24-month price lock.
  2. The changes since July are identified. Evidence: Metro Shine's office cut on three-year terms and the green program; Brightpath entering medical with an introductory price and the disinfection add-on; CleanWorks raising office from $0.095 to $0.10 and adding month-to-month and the price lock.
  3. Implications for both proposals are given as options, at least two each, tied to the figures and the customer comments. Evidence: Office: Keystone's $0.11 against Metro Shine's $0.105 and CleanWorks' $0.10, with options such as a term-based price, the reliability case, or a bundle; clinic: Keystone's $0.16 against $0.145 and $0.14, with options leaning on documented protocols and training proof, which the prospect said comes first.
  4. The 6% minimum wage rise on January 1 is noted as a cost pressure for multi-year pricing. Evidence: A sentence connecting the wage rise to any term-based pricing option.
  5. Nothing beyond the material: no invented competitor facts, market shares, or figures. Evidence: Every figure traces to the notes, rate cards, announcements or comments.
  6. One page, clearly sectioned. Evidence: About 350 to 600 words with headings for positions, changes and implications.

The attempt, one pass, unedited

Claude Fable 5.2, written 2026-11-11 00:19 UTC from the brief and the material only.

MARKET BRIEF FOR MONDAY: commercial cleaning, three main competitors
Source: July price notes and the October material only. All prices per square foot per month.

1. Where each competitor stands now
Company | Office, July to October | Medical, July to October | New since July
Keystone (us) | $0.11 | $0.16 | I have only our July prices
Metro Shine | $0.10 to $0.105 on a 3-year contract, $0.115 on a 1-year | $0.15 to $0.16 | Green certified program included free; day porter add-on $28 an hour
Brightpath | $0.12, unchanged | None to $0.145 introductory, first year | New to medical, with a certified team; electrostatic disinfection add-on $0.02
CleanWorks | $0.095 to $0.10; month-to-month $0.11 | $0.14, unchanged | 24-month price lock (July: 12-month contracts with a 90-day exit)
Also: the regional minimum wage rises 6% on January 1.

2. What changed, in short
- Office prices moved up at Metro Shine and CleanWorks by about 5%. Metro Shine now prices by term: its $0.105 needs a 3-year commitment, and its 1-year price ($0.115) is above ours.
- Metro Shine's medical price rose to our level ($0.16).
- Medical has a new entrant, Brightpath, under us at $0.145 for year one. Its price after year one is not stated. With its disinfection add-on it comes to $0.165.
- Competitors are selling terms as well as price: 3-year pricing, a 24-month lock, month-to-month.
- The wage rise lands on January 1, inside the first year of any contract signed now.

3. The two proposals at these rates (monthly)
40,000 sq ft office: Keystone $4,400. Metro Shine $4,200 (3-year) or $4,600 (1-year). CleanWorks $4,000, or $4,400 month-to-month. Brightpath $4,800.
12,000 sq ft clinic: Keystone $1,920. Metro Shine $1,920. Brightpath $1,740 in year one, $1,980 with the disinfection add-on. CleanWorks $1,680.

4. Options for the office proposal
A. Hold $0.11 on a 1-year term. We are below Metro Shine's 1-year price and $400 a month above CleanWorks. Lead with crew reliability, which a current client gave as the reason they stayed.
B. Offer a multi-year price near $0.105 ($4,200). It closes the gap the client called noticeable, gives up $200 a month, and carries the January wage rise unless the contract has an adjustment clause.
C. Hold the price and answer the green program. This depends on whether we have a comparable program to document; the material does not say.
D. Offer a price lock of our own against CleanWorks's 24 months, with the wage rise priced in.

5. Options for the clinic proposal
The prospect asked for documented disinfection protocols and proof of staff training, with price second.
A. Hold $0.16 and build the proposal around the documentation. We match Metro Shine and sit $180 to $240 a month above Brightpath's first-year price and CleanWorks.
B. Include a disinfection service at $0.16. Brightpath charges $0.02 more for its add-on, which would put us $60 a month below it like for like.
C. Price closer to the low end, for example $0.15 ($1,800). It gives up $120 a month for a buyer who says price is second.

6. What I do not have
Our own October prices and costs, the share of our cost that moves with the minimum wage, whether we hold a green certification or written disinfection protocols and training records, what each competitor's price includes (frequency and scope), and Brightpath's medical price after its first year.

The grade

Graded 2026-11-11 00:29 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.2, the model that made the attempt.

CriterionResultNote
r1passAll three competitors' current prices and terms are stated correctly.
r2passThe changes are identified for all three. The attempt reads Metro Shine's three-year office price as a rise from July's $0.10, where the rubric's evidence calls it a cut.
r3passFour options for the office and three for the clinic, tied to the monthly figures and to both customer comments.
r4passThe January wage rise is tied to the multi-year and price-lock options.
r5passEvery figure traces to the material; the monthly amounts are arithmetic on it.
r6passAbout 570 words under headings for positions, changes, the proposals and the options.

Overall: passes. No error found against the rubric. On one point the attempt and the rubric's evidence read the July figure differently, and the attempt's reading matches the material.

Earlier attempts

Claude Fable 5.1, 2026-10-01 03:44 UTC: passes

The attempt, one pass, unedited

Claude Fable 5.1, written 2026-10-01 03:44 UTC from the brief and the material only.

MARKET BRIEF, commercial cleaning, for Monday
Prepared for the sales director. Sources: the July price notes, competitor rate cards and announcements dated September 20 to October 1, and two customer comments.

Where the competitors stand now
- Metro Shine (rate card, October 1): office $0.105 per square foot per month on a 3-year contract, $0.115 on 1 year; medical $0.16; a 'green certified' program included at no charge; day porter add-on $28 an hour.
- Brightpath Janitorial (announcement, September 20): now in medical cleaning with a certified team at an introductory $0.145 for the first year; office $0.12, unchanged; a new electrostatic disinfection add-on at $0.02 per square foot per month.
- CleanWorks Co (website, September 28): office $0.10; medical $0.14; month-to-month office at $0.11; a 24-month price lock on contracts.
- Keystone, for reference (July): office $0.11, medical $0.16.

What changed since July
- Metro Shine moved office from a flat $0.10 to a term structure: cheaper than before on 3 years ($0.105), dearer on 1 year ($0.115). Medical went from $0.15 to $0.16. The green program is new and free.
- Brightpath entered medical, where it had no offering, at $0.145 for year one, and added the disinfection add-on.
- CleanWorks raised office from $0.095 to $0.10, kept medical at $0.14, and added month-to-month at $0.11 and the 24-month price lock.
- On costs: the regional minimum wage rises 6% on January 1. That presses on every competitor's labor cost and on ours, and it lands inside any 2-year or 3-year price we quote now.

What it means for next week's proposals, as options

Office building, 40,000 square feet. At $0.11 we sit above Metro Shine's 3-year $0.105 and CleanWorks' $0.10, and a current client has told us the gap is noticeable even though our reliability kept them. Options: (1) a term-based price, for example a lower rate on a 3-year term, with the January wage rise built into the math so we are not locked in below cost; (2) hold $0.11 and sell the reliability the client named, with service measures written into the proposal; (3) a bundle at or near $0.11 that includes something Metro Shine charges for or does not offer, such as day porter hours or disinfection, if our costs allow it.

Medical clinic, 12,000 square feet. At $0.16 we are above Brightpath's $0.145 introductory rate and CleanWorks' $0.14, but the prospect said documented disinfection protocols and proof of staff training come first and price second. Options: (1) hold $0.16 and lead the proposal with the protocols and the training records; (2) mirror Brightpath's structure with a first-year rate and a stated second-year rate, again with January's wage rise in the math; (3) make the protocol documentation a contract deliverable so the comparison is not on rate alone.

Things to watch. Brightpath's medical price is introductory, so its second-year rate is unknown. CleanWorks' 24-month price lock may be something prospects ask us to match.

The grade

Graded 2026-10-01 03:51 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.1, the model that made the attempt.

CriterionResultNote
r1passAll three positions with every figure from the rate cards and announcements.
r2passMetro Shine's term structure and green program, Brightpath's medical entry and add-on, CleanWorks' increase, month-to-month and price lock.
r3passThree options for each proposal, tied to the gaps and to the two customer comments, framed for the director to choose.
r4passThe wage rise is tied to multi-year pricing twice.
r5passNo competitor fact beyond the material; the 'things to watch' lines are inferences from stated facts and say so.
r6passAbout 520 words under four headings.

Overall: passes. The brief does what a director would want: the figures, the deltas, and choices rather than a recommendation. It assumes Keystone has training records to show, which the material implies through the prospect's request but does not state.

How the examples are made and graded: the method. Every task of this job, with its length and when it comes within reach: Sales Representatives of Services, Except Advertising, Insurance, Financial Services, and Travel.