The Work Bench · Stockers and Order Fillers
Recommend disposal of excess stock
The task, from O*NET: Recommend disposal of excess, defective, or obsolete stock.
Typical length 25 minutes. Time split: documents 50%, hands-on 50%. About 129,115,185 hours a year of desk work across the US go to this task.
Passes, one attempt by Claude Fable 5.2. The rubric was written 2026-10-01 03:34 UTC by Claude Fable 5.1, before the attempt (2026-11-11 00:23 UTC); the grade came last (2026-11-11 00:29 UTC).
One attempt at one task on one date, with constructed material: it is not a statement that the job, or this task in a given workplace, can be done by AI. The brief, the material and the rubric were written by Claude Fable 5.1 before its own attempt and have not changed. Claude Fable 5.2 made this attempt in a later session, from the brief and the material only, and then graded it against that rubric; each model grades its own attempt, and the earlier attempt is kept below. A person's check of a sample of grades will be published beside them.
The brief
You stock the back room at Fairmont Home & Garden. Today is October 1. The manager wants your recommendation on every item flagged in the aging report: for each, one of return to vendor, mark down, transfer, donate, or dispose, with a sentence of reason that names the store rule, and the cost value involved, totaled. Follow the rules below. Where the rules do not settle an item, say what you need to know instead of guessing.
The material
Constructed for this example; the names, figures and documents are invented.
STORE RULES - Return to vendor: allowed within 90 days of receipt for unopened goods when the vendor accepts returns (noted per line). A recalled item is returned under the vendor's recall authorization at any time. - Mark down: up to 50% for seasonal goods after the season, with clearance tags. - Transfer: to the sister store if it sells the category and the item is not seasonal-dated. - Donate: unexpired consumables and usable goods to the community partner; keep a donation receipt. - Dispose: damaged, expired, recalled-and-unreturnable, or hazardous goods, chemicals through the hazardous-waste procedure. Never donate or sell recalled or expired items. AGING REPORT (item; quantity on hand; unit cost; received; condition; notes) 1. Patio umbrellas, 9 ft, striped; 14; $42.00; received April 2; unopened; vendor accepts returns; season ended. 2. Pool chlorine tablets, 5 lb; 22; $19.50; received May 10; sealed; expires December 2027; vendor does not accept returns; hazardous category. 3. Garden hose, 50 ft, lot B; 30; $11.00; received June 15; recalled September 12 for coupling failure; vendor issued a recall notice with a return authorization. 4. Flower bulbs, tulip mix; 60 bags; $3.20; received August 20; packaging intact; plant-by date November 30, 2026; sister store sells bulbs. 5. Charcoal, 20 lb; 48 bags; $9.00; received March 1; 6 bags torn and wet; vendor does not accept returns; sister store sells charcoal. 6. Holiday string lights, last year's; 25 boxes; $7.50; received October 2025; unopened; vendor window passed. 7. Bird seed, 20 lb; 15 bags; $14.00; received July 8; expires October 15, 2026; vendor does not accept returns; the community partner accepts pet and wildlife feed. 8. Paint, interior latex, custom-tinted returns; 9 gallons; $24.00; opened and tinted; cannot be returned; usable. 9. Lawn fertilizer with weed control; 11 bags; $26.00; received February 12; 3 bags with broken seams, leaking; chemical category.
The rubric, written before the attempt
- Every item gets one recommendation from the five allowed, with a one-sentence reason that names the rule. Evidence: Nine items, one action each, a rule in each reason.
- The 90-day return window is applied by date. Evidence: On October 1, anything received before about July 3 is outside the window: umbrellas, chlorine, charcoal, lights and fertilizer are not returnable; the recalled hose is returned under its recall authorization regardless.
- Hazard and safety rules are respected. Evidence: The recalled hose is never donated or sold; the leaking fertilizer and the wet charcoal are disposed of, the fertilizer through the hazardous-waste procedure; the sealed, unexpired chlorine is not disposed of.
- Expiry is handled. Evidence: Bird seed donated with a receipt, or marked down, before October 15; bulbs sold or donated before November 30 and not transferred, since they are seasonal-dated.
- Open questions are stated where the rules do not settle the item. Evidence: Whether to hold the string lights for the coming season rather than mark them down; whether the sister store sells pool supplies, for the chlorine; the paint as donation versus mis-tint markdown.
- Cost values are right per item and in total, with the disposed portion identified. Evidence: $588.00, $429.00, $330.00, $192.00, $432.00, $187.50, $210.00, $216.00, $286.00; total $2,870.50; disposed: charcoal $54.00 and fertilizer $78.00.
The attempt, one pass, unedited
Claude Fable 5.2, written 2026-11-11 00:23 UTC from the brief and the material only.
AGING REPORT RECOMMENDATIONS, October 1 No. | Item | Recommendation | Cost value 1 | Patio umbrellas, 14 | Mark down | $588.00 2 | Pool chlorine tablets, 22 | Mark down, if the store treats pool chemicals as seasonal (need to know) | $429.00 3 | Garden hose, lot B, 30 | Return to vendor | $330.00 4 | Tulip bulbs, 60 bags | Return to vendor, if the vendor accepts returns (need to know); otherwise donate before November 30 | $192.00 5 | Charcoal, 48 bags | Dispose of the 6 torn, wet bags; transfer the 42 sound bags | $54.00 and $378.00 6 | Holiday string lights, 25 boxes | Mark down | $187.50 7 | Bird seed, 15 bags | Donate, before October 15 | $210.00 8 | Tinted latex paint, 9 gallons | Donate, if the community partner takes opened paint (need to know) | $216.00 9 | Lawn fertilizer with weed control, 11 bags | Dispose of the 3 leaking bags; the 8 sound bags are not settled by the rules (need to know) | $78.00 and $208.00 Total cost value of everything flagged | | | $2,870.50 Reasons, by item 1. Umbrellas: mark down. The return rule allows 90 days from receipt, and these came in April 2, 182 days ago, so the vendor return is closed even though the vendor accepts returns. The mark-down rule covers seasonal goods after the season, up to 50%, with clearance tags. 2. Chlorine tablets: mark down, pending your answer. They cannot go back (the vendor does not accept returns). They are sealed and good until December 2027, so the dispose rule does not apply; if any are ever disposed of, they go through the hazardous-waste procedure. The mark-down rule fits if the store counts pool chemicals as seasonal goods after the season. I would not donate a hazardous chemical under the donate rule without your say. What I need to know: are pool chemicals seasonal for mark-down, and does the sister store sell them (the transfer rule would then be an alternative). 3. Garden hose, lot B: return to vendor. The return rule says a recalled item goes back under the vendor's recall authorization at any time, and the vendor has issued one. They must come off the floor now and be tagged do not sell: the rules say never donate or sell a recalled item. 4. Tulip bulbs: return to vendor if the line allows it. They were received August 20, so the 90-day return window runs to November 18 and the packaging is intact, but the report does not say whether this vendor accepts returns. The transfer rule excludes them, because they are seasonal-dated (plant by November 30, 2026), even though the sister store sells bulbs. The mark-down rule is for after the season, and after the plant-by date they cannot be sold. If the vendor will not take them, the donate rule applies while they are unexpired: donate what is left before November 30, with a receipt. What I need to know: whether the vendor accepts returns. 5. Charcoal: two actions. The 6 torn, wet bags are damaged, so the dispose rule applies ($54.00). The 42 sound bags meet the transfer rule: the sister store sells charcoal and the item is not seasonal-dated ($378.00). The vendor does not accept returns. If the sister store does not want them, the mark-down rule for seasonal goods after the season is the fallback. 6. Holiday string lights: mark down. The vendor window has passed. They are last year's seasonal goods, so the mark-down rule applies, up to 50%, with clearance tags. 7. Bird seed: donate now. The vendor does not accept returns. The donate rule covers unexpired consumables, the community partner accepts wildlife feed, and the seed expires October 15, 2026, two weeks from today. Keep the donation receipt. Any bag still here after October 15 must be disposed of, since expired items are never donated or sold. 8. Tinted paint: donate, if the partner takes it. It is opened and tinted and cannot be returned, but it is usable, and the donate rule covers usable goods. The report does not say whether the community partner accepts opened paint. If it does not, no rule fits cleanly: it is not seasonal for mark-down and not damaged or expired for disposal. What I need to know: whether the partner accepts it. 9. Fertilizer with weed control: the 3 bags with broken seams are damaged chemicals, so the dispose rule applies, through the hazardous-waste procedure ($78.00). They should be contained now. The 8 sound bags ($208.00) are past the 90-day return window (received February 12). The rules allow a transfer if the sister store sells the category, or a mark-down if the store treats fertilizer as seasonal and the season as over; the report says neither. What I need to know: whether the sister store sells lawn chemicals, whether these count as seasonal, and whether the sound bags were contaminated by the leaking ones. Totals by action, at cost Action | Settled by the rules | Waiting on an answer Return to vendor | $330.00 (hoses) | $192.00 (bulbs) Mark down | $775.50 (umbrellas, string lights) | $429.00 (chlorine) Transfer | $378.00 (charcoal, 42 bags) | $208.00 (fertilizer, 8 bags, if transfer is chosen) Donate | $210.00 (bird seed) | $216.00 (paint) Dispose | $132.00 (6 charcoal, 3 fertilizer) | Total | $1,825.50 | $1,045.00 All flagged stock: $2,870.50. Time-sensitive: the hoses (recalled, pull today), the bird seed (expires October 15) and the bulbs (return window to November 18, plant-by November 30).
The grade
Graded 2026-11-11 00:29 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.2, the model that made the attempt.
| Criterion | Result | Note |
|---|---|---|
| r1 | pass | Each of the nine items has an action with the rule named. Two lots are split by condition, three depend on a stated answer, and the 8 sound fertilizer bags are left open with what is needed. The reasons run to several sentences each, not one. |
| r2 | pass | The 90-day window is applied by date; the recalled hose goes back under its authorization regardless. |
| r3 | pass | The hose is never sold or donated, the leaking fertilizer and wet charcoal are disposed of, and the sealed chlorine is kept. |
| r4 | pass | Bird seed donated with a receipt before October 15; bulbs not transferred, returned or donated before November 30. |
| r5 | pass | Open questions stated for the chlorine, the bulbs, the paint and the sound fertilizer. Holding the string lights for the coming season is not raised. |
| r6 | pass | All nine values and the $2,870.50 total are right, with $54.00 and $78.00 disposed. |
Overall: passes. No error found against the rubric. The reasons are longer than a sentence, and one open question the rubric names, holding the lights for the season, is not asked.
Earlier attempts
Claude Fable 5.1, 2026-10-01 03:43 UTC: passes
The attempt, one pass, unedited
Claude Fable 5.1, written 2026-10-01 03:43 UTC from the brief and the material only.
RECOMMENDATIONS ON THE AGING REPORT, October 1 | Item | Qty | Cost value | Recommendation | Reason | |---|---|---|---|---| | 1. Patio umbrellas | 14 | $588.00 | Mark down, up to 50%, clearance tags | Received April 2, outside the 90-day return window; seasonal goods after the season. | | 2. Pool chlorine tablets | 22 | $429.00 | Mark down; transfer instead if the sister store sells pool supplies | No returns; sealed and good until December 2027, so not disposal; seasonal after the pool season. Question below. | | 3. Garden hose, lot B | 30 | $330.00 | Return to vendor under the recall authorization | Recalled September 12; recalled items are returned under the authorization at any time and never sold or donated. | | 4. Tulip bulbs | 60 | $192.00 | Mark down now to sell before November 30; donate any left in late November, with a receipt | The plant-by date makes them seasonal-dated, so no transfer; an unexpired consumable, so donation is allowed before the date. | | 5. Charcoal | 48 | $432.00 | 42 good bags: transfer to the sister store. 6 torn and wet bags ($54.00): dispose | The sister store sells charcoal and the item is not seasonal-dated; damaged goods are disposed of. | | 6. Holiday string lights | 25 | $187.50 | Mark down up to 50%, unless the manager prefers to hold them for the coming season | Unopened; vendor window passed; last season's goods. Question below. | | 7. Bird seed | 15 | $210.00 | Donate to the community partner now, with a receipt | Expires October 15; the partner accepts wildlife feed; unexpired consumables may be donated; two weeks is too short to sell 15 bags. | | 8. Custom-tinted paint returns | 9 | $216.00 | Donate as usable goods, or mark down as mis-tints | Cannot be returned; usable. Question below. | | 9. Lawn fertilizer with weed control | 11 | $286.00 | 8 intact bags: mark down (seasonal, outside the return window). 3 leaking bags ($78.00): dispose through the hazardous-waste procedure | Received February 12, outside 90 days; chemical category, so the leaking bags go through the chemical procedure. | Totals: cost value under review $2,870.50. Of that, to dispose: $132.00 (charcoal $54.00, fertilizer $78.00). To return under the recall: $330.00. The rest is sold down, transferred or donated. What I need to know - Chlorine: does the sister store sell pool supplies? If so, a transfer beats a markdown. - String lights: the rule says mark down after the season, but the holiday season is ahead of us. Do you want to hold them at full price instead? - Paint: donate to the partner, or mark down as mis-tints at the register? Either fits the rules.
The grade
Graded 2026-10-01 03:46 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.1, the model that made the attempt.
| Criterion | Result | Note |
|---|---|---|
| r1 | pass | Nine items, one action each, the rule named in every reason; two items split by condition, which the rules require. |
| r2 | pass | Dates applied; the recalled hose returned under its authorization. |
| r3 | pass | Hose not sold or donated; leaking fertilizer and wet charcoal disposed of, the fertilizer through the chemical procedure; chlorine kept. |
| r4 | pass | Bird seed donated before October 15; bulbs sold or donated before November 30 and not transferred. |
| r5 | pass | All three open questions named. |
| r6 | pass | Every line value and the totals check; the disposed portion is $132.00. |
Overall: passes. The recommendations follow the rules item by item and stop where the rules stop. The two split recommendations (charcoal, fertilizer) are the right reading of damaged partial lots.
How the examples are made and graded: the method. Every task of this job, with its length and when it comes within reach: Stockers and Order Fillers.