Skip to content
STRATUSWORKFORCE SCAN

The Work Bench · First-Line Supervisors of Food Preparation and Serving Workers

Specify portions, sequences and station layouts

The task, from O*NET: Specify food portions and courses, production and time sequences, and workstation and equipment arrangements.

Typical length 50 minutes. Time split: documents 80%, in person 20%. About 122,942,470 hours a year of desk work across the US go to this task.

Passes with named fixes, one attempt by Claude Fable 5.2. The rubric was written 2026-10-01 03:42 UTC by Claude Fable 5.1, before the attempt (2026-11-11 00:12 UTC); the grade came last (2026-11-11 00:29 UTC).

One attempt at one task on one date, with constructed material: it is not a statement that the job, or this task in a given workplace, can be done by AI. The brief, the material and the rubric were written by Claude Fable 5.1 before its own attempt and have not changed. Claude Fable 5.2 made this attempt in a later session, from the brief and the material only, and then graded it against that rubric; each model grades its own attempt, and the earlier attempt is kept below. A person's check of a sample of grades will be published beside them.

The brief

You supervise the kitchen at the Harbor Street Conference Center. Saturday's event is a plated lunch for 120 guests at 12:30, three courses, with 8 vegetarian and 4 gluten-free guests. From the menu, the recipe yields, the staffing and the equipment below, write the production plan: portions and quantities per course, the production timeline worked backward from 12:30, station assignments and the layout of the plating line, and the plating sequence, with the holding temperatures that apply. Flag anything the numbers do not support.

The material

Constructed for this example; the names, figures and documents are invented.

MENU AND YIELDS
Course 1: tomato and basil soup, 8 oz portions, served hot and held at 165 F or above; one recipe yields 4 quarts (16 portions). A bread roll with it.
Course 2: roast chicken breast with lemon, one 6 oz breast per guest; a pan of 24 breasts roasts in 35 minutes at 400 F. Herbed potatoes, 5 oz portions; one hotel pan yields 40 portions, 45 minutes at 400 F; the standard seasoning contains flour, and a gluten-free seasoning is on hand. Green beans, 4 oz portions; a 5 lb bag yields 20 portions; blanch 4 minutes ahead, finish 3 minutes before plating. Vegetarian main: stuffed pepper, one recipe yields 12, bake 30 minutes at 375 F. Gluten-free guests: the chicken plate is gluten-free if the roll is omitted and the potatoes use the gluten-free seasoning; the soup is gluten-free.
Course 3: lemon tart, each tart cuts into 8 slices; a gluten-free tart (8 slices) from the pastry supplier is already ordered. Berries, 1 pint per 6 plates.

STAFF ON SATURDAY: you, two cooks (A and B), one prep cook (C), two dish and utility staff. Six servers, who do not work in the kitchen.

EQUIPMENT: two convection ovens, each holding 4 full hotel pans; a 6-burner range; one 10-gallon steam kettle; two hot holding cabinets, each holding 10 hotel pans; a walk-in cooler; a 12-foot plating line with a heat lamp over 6 feet of it.

SERVICE: each server carries 2 plates, so 12 plates leave per pass; the dining room is 60 seconds away. The client wants every main on the tables within 12 minutes of the first.

The rubric, written before the attempt

  1. Quantities are right for every course. Evidence: Soup 30 quarts (7.5 recipes), which fits the 40-quart kettle in one batch; 116 rolls; 112 chicken breasts in 5 pans; 3 pans of potatoes with the gluten-free seasoning on at least the 4 gluten-free portions; 6 bags of green beans; one recipe of 12 stuffed peppers for 8 vegetarian plates; 15 regular tarts (116 slices) plus the gluten-free tart; 20 pints of berries.
  2. Oven capacity is handled. Evidence: Nine pans (5 chicken, 3 potatoes, 1 peppers) against 8 slots, so the potatoes (45 minutes) and peppers are staggered against the chicken (35 minutes) with the holding cabinets in between, and the times are given.
  3. A timed plan runs backward from 12:30. Evidence: Soup plating starting about ten minutes before service; the mains timed so that all 120 are on the tables within 12 minutes of the first; dessert after; every step with a clock time.
  4. The service math is done. Evidence: 12 plates a pass and a one-minute walk, so 10 passes for 120 mains within 12 minutes means plates ready at about 10 a minute, and the line is staffed and sequenced for that, with who adds what to the plate in what order.
  5. Stations, layout and holding are specified. Evidence: You, cooks A and B, prep cook C and the two utility staff assigned by course and task; the 12-foot line with the mains under the 6-foot heat lamp; soup and hot food held at 165 F or above; vegetarian and gluten-free plates kept apart and marked.
  6. Flags where the numbers are tight, and nothing invented. Evidence: At least the oven slots, the holding time of the chicken, and the 6 feet of heat lamp for 120 plates; no equipment, staff or quantities beyond the material.

The attempt, one pass, unedited

Claude Fable 5.2, written 2026-11-11 00:12 UTC from the brief and the material only.

PRODUCTION PLAN: Saturday plated lunch, 120 guests, service 12:30

Assumptions to confirm first
- The 4 gluten-free guests eat the chicken plate and the 8 vegetarians the stuffed pepper, with no guest in both groups. That gives 108 standard chicken plates, 4 gluten-free chicken plates and 8 vegetarian plates.
- Vegetarian plates get the same potatoes and green beans.
- "A pan of 24 breasts" is a full hotel pan.
- Course times: soup at 12:30, mains from 12:55, dessert from about 1:40. The client gave only 12:30.

1. Portions and quantities
Course 1
- Soup: 120 portions of 8 oz = 30 quarts. 7.5 recipes needed; make 8 recipes = 32 quarts (8 gallons, 128 portions). Fits the 10-gallon kettle.
- Rolls: 116 (none for the 4 gluten-free guests). Have 120 on hand.
Course 2
- Chicken: 112 breasts needed; roast 5 pans = 120 (8 spare).
- Potatoes: 116 standard portions = 3 hotel pans (120 portions). Gluten-free: 4 portions, 1 separate small pan with the gluten-free seasoning (make 8 portions).
- Green beans: 120 portions = 6 bags exactly, with no spare. Use 7 bags (35 lb, 140 portions).
- Stuffed peppers: 8 needed; 1 recipe = 12 (4 spare).
Course 3
- Lemon tart: 116 standard slices = 14.5 tarts; have 15 (120 slices). Gluten-free tart: 1 (8 slices) for 4 guests, already ordered.
- Berries: 120 plates at 1 pint per 6 = 20 pints; have 22.

2. Temperatures
- Soup: hold at 165 F or above (menu requirement). Check and log every 30 minutes.
- Chicken: cook to 165 F internal. Stuffed peppers: 165 F internal.
- All hot food in the holding cabinets and on the line: 135 F or above.
- Tarts, berries and blanched beans waiting to be finished: 41 F or below in the walk-in.

3. Timeline, worked back from 12:30
Friday: bake or receive the tarts; receive the gluten-free tart; wash berries. (See flag 6.)
9:30 Cook B starts 8 recipes of soup in the kettle. Prep cook C blanches the beans in pots on the range, 4 minutes a batch, chills them and holds them in the walk-in. The kettle is taken by the soup.
10:30 Cook A seasons and pans the chicken (5 pans) and assembles the peppers. Cook B seasons potatoes: 3 standard pans, then the gluten-free pan last with a clean bowl, gloves and utensils, labeled and covered.
11:00 Oven 2 at 400 F, oven 1 at 375 F. Holding cabinets on. Plates and soup bowls warming.
11:05 Potatoes into oven 2 (4 pans, the gluten-free pan on the top rack). Out 11:50, into cabinet 1.
11:15 Peppers into oven 1. Out 11:45, into cabinet 1, covered. Oven 1 up to 400 F.
11:30 Soup finished, holding at 165 F or above. Line set (section 4).
12:00 Chicken in: 4 pans in oven 1, 1 pan in oven 2. Out 12:35 at 165 F internal, into cabinet 2, covered.
12:15 Servers set rolls. Cut the tarts, hold in the walk-in.
12:25 Ladle soup into warm bowls at the kettle, 12 at a time, as servers return (Cook B and C; utility 1 feeds bowls). First bowls leave at 12:29 (see flag 2).
12:45 C finishes the first batch of beans (3 minutes).
12:48 Special plates: I build the 4 gluten-free plates at a separate cleaned table; Cook A builds the 8 vegetarian plates. Cover, tag with table and seat.
12:55 First pass leaves with the 12 special plates. The line then runs the 108 standard plates in 9 passes of 12. C finishes the beans in two more batches as the line runs.
1:15 After the last mains leave, C and the utility staff plate dessert on the cold end: gluten-free slices first, with a clean knife and board, tagged. Plated tarts wait in the walk-in.
1:40 Dessert out.

4. Stations and the plating line
Line, 12 feet, running toward the pass, with the heat lamp over the 6 feet nearest the pass:
- Feet 0 to 2: warm plates. Utility 1 feeds plates and wipes spills.
- Feet 2 to 4: potatoes. Cook B.
- Feet 4 to 6: chicken. Cook A.
- Feet 6 to 8 (lamp begins): green beans. Prep cook C, finishing batches on the range behind.
- Feet 8 to 9: lemon and pan juices, rim wiped, plate checked. Me.
- Feet 9 to 12 (under the lamp): landing space for 12 finished plates, picked up by the servers.
Utility 2 runs full pans from the cabinets and takes empties.
The gluten-free plates are built off the line at a cleaned table, from the labeled pan, before the line starts.

5. Plating sequence for a main
Potatoes at the back of the plate, chicken leaned on the potatoes, beans alongside, lemon and juices over the chicken, wipe, check, onto the landing space. Twelve plates up, call the pass.
Order of plates: the 4 gluten-free, the 8 vegetarian, then the 108 standard.

6. Flags: what the numbers do not support
1. The 12-minute target for mains cannot be met as staffed. Six servers at 2 plates is 12 plates a pass, so 120 plates is 10 passes. The dining room is 60 seconds away, so a round trip is at least 2 minutes before any time to set plates down. Passes leave at minutes 0, 2, 4 and so on; the tenth leaves at minute 18. The last plates land about 18 minutes after the first, 6 minutes over. In 12 minutes only 7 passes (84 plates) can land. To land 120 in 7 passes takes 18 plates a pass: 9 carriers at 2 plates, 6 servers at 3 plates, or trays. The line would also have to plate 9 plates a minute, which one line of four people will not sustain; 6 a minute is realistic. Ask the client to choose: 3 more servers or tray service plus a second plating team, or accept about 20 minutes.
2. The same arithmetic applies to the soup: with 2 bowls a server the last guest is served about 18 minutes after the first. Trays would fix it.
3. Oven space and temperature. Chicken (5 pans) and potatoes (4 pans) both need 400 F and total 9 pans against 8 oven slots, and the peppers need 375 F. The plan staggers them, which means potatoes and peppers hold about an hour before plating. Both hold acceptably, covered, at 135 F or above.
4. Green beans: 6 bags is exactly 120 portions with nothing spare. Order 7.
5. Soup recipe time is not given. I have allowed 2 hours. Also confirm the soup is made without meat stock, or the 8 vegetarians cannot have it.
6. Tarts: 15 standard tarts are needed and the material gives no recipe time or source for them. The ovens are full on Saturday morning, so they must be baked Friday or bought in.
7. Gluten-free guests get no roll. Ask whether the client wants a gluten-free roll bought in. Confirm whether the stuffed pepper contains gluten in case a vegetarian guest is also gluten-free.
8. Seating: I need the table and seat of the 12 special-diet guests to tag their plates.
9. Gluten-free potatoes share an oven with the floured pans. Covered and on the top rack is workable; using the gluten-free seasoning on all four pans would remove the risk if there is enough of it. I do not know how much is on hand.

The grade

Graded 2026-11-11 00:29 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.2, the model that made the attempt.

CriterionResultNote
r1passQuantities right for every course. The attempt makes 8 soup recipes for the 7.5 needed, adds a separate small pan for the gluten-free potatoes and suggests a seventh bag of beans as a margin.
r2passOven slots counted against the pans and the potatoes and peppers staggered ahead of the chicken, with clock times and the holding cabinets between.
r3fail (minor)Every step has a clock time and dessert follows, but soup plating starts 5 minutes before service, not about 10, and the mains are not timed to land within 12 minutes: the plan runs them over about 18. Fix: if the 12-minute target stands, re-time the mains for it with the added carriers the attempt names.
r4fail (minor)The service arithmetic is done, but it reaches a different answer from the rubric's: counting the servers' walk back, it finds six servers at two plates need about 18 minutes, and it staffs one line for about 6 plates a minute instead of the 10 the rubric expects. Fix: set out the two-team line that plates about 10 a minute for the case where the client adds carriers or trays.
r5fail (minor)All six people are assigned and the special plates are kept apart and tagged, but hot food other than the soup is held at 135 F or above, not the 165 F the rubric names, and the chicken and potato stations sit outside the lamp's 6 feet. Fix: hold all hot food at 165 F if that is the house standard and put the chicken under the lamp.
r6fail (minor)The oven slots are flagged, but not the chicken's holding time or the 6 feet of heat lamp. Extra servers and trays are raised only as questions for the client. Fix: add the two missing flags.

Overall: passes with named fixes. Quantities and the oven plan are right. The attempt disputes the 12-minute service target on the stated walk time and plans around that instead of meeting it, so it does not match the rubric's service plan; a reader can check the arithmetic in flag 1 of the attempt. It also uses 135 F as the general hot-holding figure and misses two of the three flags the rubric names.

Earlier attempts

Claude Fable 5.1, 2026-10-01 03:50 UTC: passes

The attempt, one pass, unedited

Claude Fable 5.1, written 2026-10-01 03:50 UTC from the brief and the material only.

PRODUCTION PLAN, Saturday plated lunch, 120 covers at 12:30 (8 vegetarian, 4 gluten-free)

Quantities
- Course 1, soup: 120 x 8 oz = 960 oz = 30 quarts = 7.5 recipes, one batch in the 10-gallon (40-quart) kettle, held at 165 F or above. Rolls: 116 (no roll on the 4 gluten-free plates).
- Course 2, mains: chicken 112 breasts (120 less 8 vegetarian) = 5 pans of 24 (120 capacity, 8 spare). Potatoes 120 x 5 oz = 3 hotel pans of 40; one pan made with the gluten-free seasoning and used for the 4 gluten-free plates and extras, the other two with the standard seasoning. Green beans 120 x 4 oz = 480 oz = 30 lb = 6 bags. Stuffed peppers: one recipe of 12 for the 8 vegetarian plates (4 spare). Gluten-free plates: chicken, gluten-free-seasoned potatoes, beans, no roll.
- Course 3: 116 regular slices = 15 tarts (120 slices, 4 spare) plus the gluten-free tart (8 slices, 4 used). Berries 120 / 6 = 20 pints.

Oven plan (2 ovens x 4 pans = 8 slots; 9 pans to cook)
- 11:00 to 11:45: potatoes, 3 pans, oven 1 at 400 F. 11:15 to 11:45: stuffed peppers, oven 2 at 375 F; oven 2 is then raised to 400 F.
- 11:45: potatoes to holding cabinet 1 (165 F or above); peppers to holding cabinet 2.
- 11:50 to 12:25: chicken, 5 pans, 4 in oven 1 and 1 in oven 2, at 400 F. Out at 12:25 to holding cabinet 1.
- Green beans: blanched 4 minutes by 11:30 and chilled; finished 3 minutes on the range in two batches at 12:45 and 12:50.

Timeline backward from 12:30
- 10:30: soup started in the kettle (you); rolls counted; dessert plates to the walk-in.
- 11:00 to 12:25: ovens as above; cook A on potatoes and peppers, cook B on chicken.
- 11:30: beans blanched and chilled (prep cook C); soup temperature checked.
- 12:15: soup temperature checked; soup bowls staged; the line set.
- 12:18 to 12:30: soup plated at 10 bowls a minute (two ladling, one adding the roll); 12 bowls per server pass, 10 passes; course on the tables from 12:30.
- 12:45 and 12:50: beans finished on the range (C).
- 12:50: soup course clearing begins (utility staff).
- 12:55 to 13:07: mains plated at 10 plates a minute and carried 12 per pass, 10 passes, so the last main is down within 12 minutes of the first. Vegetarian (8) and gluten-free (4) plates are plated first on a marked tray at the end of the line and carried by one named server.
- 13:10 onward: dessert plated by prep cook C and one utility from cold plates; gluten-free slices on a marked plate.
- 13:30: dessert served.

Stations and layout
- Kettle: soup, you, with temperature checks at 11:30 and 12:15.
- Ovens and holding: cook A, potatoes and peppers; cook B, chicken. Both move to the line at 12:50.
- Range: prep cook C, beans at 12:45.
- Plating line, 12 feet, left to right: warm plate stack; potatoes (cook A); chicken (cook B); beans and lemon (prep cook C); check and wipe (you). The heat lamp covers the last 6 feet, where finished plates wait in rows of 12 so each server pass lifts a full set.
- Dish and utility: one on pots and the kettle, one running clean plates and the dessert plates from the walk-in; both clear the soup course from 12:50.
- Servers: 6, 2 plates each, 12 per pass, 60 seconds to the room.

Holding temperatures: soup at 165 F or above in the kettle; chicken, potatoes and peppers in the holding cabinets at 165 F or above until plated; beans finished to order; dessert on cold plates from the walk-in.

Flags
- Oven slots: nine pans against eight, so the potatoes and peppers cook first and hold about 70 minutes, which is long for potatoes. Alternative: 2 potato pans at 11:00 and the third with the chicken at 11:50 (5 chicken plus 1 potato uses 6 of the 8 slots).
- Chicken holding: out at 12:25, plated from 12:55, 30 minutes in the cabinet. Moving the chicken later risks the 12:55 start; this is the tightest point in the plan.
- Heat lamp: 6 feet of lamp holds about 24 plates, so the line must plate at the servers' pace of 12 plates a minute and not run ahead.
- Staffing: three on the line plus you is the minimum for 10 plates a minute; the utility staff are clearing soup at the same time, so if clearing falls behind, the soup bowls stay on the tables until the mains are down.

The grade

Graded 2026-10-01 03:54 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.1, the model that made the attempt.

CriterionResultNote
r1passEvery quantity right, including the gluten-free potato pan, 15 tarts plus the gluten-free one, and 20 pints.
r2passPotatoes and peppers staggered ahead of the chicken with holding in between, times given, and an alternative offered.
r3passClock times from 10:30 through 13:30, soup plating from 12:18, mains 12:55 to 13:07.
r4pass10 plates a minute, 10 passes, rows of 12 under the lamp, the line sequence named by person.
r5passEvery person assigned; the line laid out; holding at 165 F or above; marked trays for the special plates.
r6passOven slots, chicken holding, the lamp and staffing all flagged; nothing beyond the material.

Overall: passes. The plan does the arithmetic, respects the equipment and names the tight points. A chef may prefer the chicken out later than 12:25; the attempt says so itself.

How the examples are made and graded: the method. Every task of this job, with its length and when it comes within reach: First-Line Supervisors of Food Preparation and Serving Workers.