The Work Bench · Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks
Compare printouts with journals
The task, from O*NET: Compare computer printouts to manually maintained journals to determine if they match.
Typical length 38 minutes. Time split: documents 100%. About 146,634,296 hours a year of desk work across the US go to this task.
Passes with named fixes, one attempt by Claude Fable 5.2. The rubric was written 2026-10-01 03:34 UTC by Claude Fable 5.1, before the attempt (2026-11-11 00:12 UTC); the grade came last (2026-11-11 00:29 UTC).
One attempt at one task on one date, with constructed material: it is not a statement that the job, or this task in a given workplace, can be done by AI. The brief, the material and the rubric were written by Claude Fable 5.1 before its own attempt and have not changed. Claude Fable 5.2 made this attempt in a later session, from the brief and the material only, and then graded it against that rubric; each model grades its own attempt, and the earlier attempt is kept below. A person's check of a sample of grades will be published beside them.
The brief
You keep the books at Riverbend Tool Rental. The accounting system's cash receipts printout for the week of September 22 to 26 does not agree with the handwritten cash receipts journal kept at the counter. Compare them line by line, list every difference, say which record you believe is right and why, using the other records available, and give the corrected weekly total. Do not change either record; your note goes to the owner with recommended corrections.
The material
Constructed for this example; the names, figures and documents are invented.
SYSTEM PRINTOUT (receipt number, date, customer, amount) 4101, Sep 22, Alder Landscaping, $340.00 4102, Sep 22, M. Dutton, $85.00 4103, Sep 23, Brightwater Builders, $1,260.00 4104, Sep 23, K. Sato, $120.00 4105, Sep 24, Alder Landscaping, $340.00 4106, Sep 24, Ridge Line Roofing, $575.00 4107, Sep 25, P. Nwosu, $65.00 4108, Sep 25, Brightwater Builders, $890.00 4109, Sep 26, Harbor Street Clinic, $210.00 4110, Sep 26, L. Fernandez, $45.00 Printout total: $3,930.00 COUNTER JOURNAL (handwritten, transcribed) 4101, 9/22, Alder Landscaping, 340.00 4102, 9/22, M. Dutton, 85.00 4103, 9/23, Brightwater Builders, 1,620.00 4104, 9/23, K. Sato, 120.00 4105, 9/24, Alder Landscaping, 340.00 (margin note: 'same as Mon? check') 4106, 9/24, Ridge Line Roofing, 575.00 4107, 9/25, P. Nwosu, 65.00 4108, 9/25, Brightwater Builders, 890.00 4109, 9/26, Harbor Street Clinic, 210.00 4110, 9/26, L. Fernandez, 45.00 4111, 9/26, cash sale, no name, 30.00 Journal total as written: 4,320.00 OTHER RECORDS Bank deposit slips for the week (each day's receipts deposited the next banking day): Sep 23, $425.00; Sep 24, $1,380.00; Sep 25, $915.00; Sep 26, $955.00; Sep 29, $285.00. Deposits total $3,960.00. Brightwater Builders invoice 2291, dated Sep 23, for $1,260.00, marked paid. Alder Landscaping's account shows two separate rentals, Sep 22 and Sep 24, $340.00 each.
The rubric, written before the attempt
- Every difference between the two records is found. Evidence: Receipt 4103 ($1,260.00 in the system, $1,620.00 in the journal); receipt 4111 ($30.00 cash sale in the journal, absent from the system); the margin question on 4105 addressed.
- Each difference is resolved with evidence from the other records. Evidence: 4103 is a transposition in the journal, supported by invoice 2291 and the Sep 24 deposit of $1,380.00 (1,260 plus 120); 4111 is a receipt never entered in the system, supported by the Sep 29 deposit of $285.00 (210 plus 45 plus 30); 4105 is a real second rental per Alder's account, not a duplicate.
- The corrected weekly total is $3,960.00, shown to agree with the bank deposits, and both record totals are reconciled to it. Evidence: Printout $3,930.00 is short the $30.00 receipt; journal $4,320.00 is $360.00 high from the transposition.
- Neither record is altered; corrections are recommended for the owner's approval. Evidence: Enter receipt 4111 in the system; correct journal line 4103 to $1,260.00; clear the margin note on 4105.
- All arithmetic is right. Evidence: Deposit sums per day, the totals and the differences all check.
- A short plain note with a line-by-line table of the differences. Evidence: A table of the differing lines and a few sentences.
The attempt, one pass, unedited
Claude Fable 5.2, written 2026-11-11 00:12 UTC from the brief and the material only.
To: Owner, Riverbend Tool Rental Re: Cash receipts, week of September 22 to 26: system printout against the counter journal Summary The two records differ in two places, and the journal carries one open question that I checked. After the corrections below, both records and the bank deposits agree at $3,960.00 for the week. I have not changed either record. Line-by-line comparison Receipts 4101, 4102, 4104, 4106, 4107, 4108, 4109 and 4110 agree in date, customer and amount. Difference 1. Receipt 4103, Sep 23, Brightwater Builders - Printout: $1,260.00. Journal: $1,620.00. Difference: $360.00. - The printout is right. Invoice 2291, dated Sep 23 and marked paid, is for $1,260.00. The Sep 24 deposit of $1,380.00 equals the Sep 23 receipts only at that amount ($1,260.00 plus $120.00 from K. Sato). The journal entry looks like two digits switched when it was written (a difference of $360 divides evenly by 9, which is typical of a transposition). Difference 2. Receipt 4111, Sep 26, cash sale, no name, $30.00 - In the journal, missing from the printout. - The journal is right. The Sep 29 deposit of $285.00 equals the Sep 26 receipts only if the $30.00 is included ($210.00 + $45.00 + $30.00). The cash was taken in and banked but never entered in the system. Checked, no difference. Receipt 4105, Sep 24, Alder Landscaping, $340.00 - Both records show it. The journal's margin note asks whether it repeats Monday's receipt 4101. - It is not a duplicate. Alder's account shows two separate rentals, Sep 22 and Sep 24, at $340.00 each, and the Sep 25 deposit of $915.00 equals the Sep 24 receipts with it included ($340.00 + $575.00). Totals - Printout total: $3,930.00. It adds correctly, but it is $30.00 short (receipt 4111). - Journal total as written: $4,320.00. It adds correctly, but it is $360.00 over (receipt 4103). - The $390.00 gap between the two totals is fully explained: $360.00 + $30.00. - Corrected weekly total: $3,960.00 (printout $3,930.00 + $30.00; journal $4,320.00 - $360.00). Check against the bank Day by day, the corrected receipts equal the next banking day's deposit: - Sep 22 receipts $425.00 = Sep 23 deposit $425.00 - Sep 23 receipts $1,380.00 = Sep 24 deposit $1,380.00 - Sep 24 receipts $915.00 = Sep 25 deposit $915.00 - Sep 25 receipts $955.00 = Sep 26 deposit $955.00 - Sep 26 receipts $285.00 = Sep 29 deposit $285.00 Deposits total $3,960.00, the same as the corrected total. Recommended corrections, for your approval 1. Journal, receipt 4103: strike through 1,620.00 with a single line, write 1,260.00 beside it, initial and date it, and reference invoice 2291. Restate the journal's weekly total as 3,960.00 the same way. 2. System: enter receipt 4111, Sep 26, cash sale, $30.00, so the printout total becomes $3,960.00. 3. Journal, receipt 4105: mark the margin note as checked, two separate rentals per Alder's account. One thing to consider: the $30.00 cash sale was written in the journal but not keyed. Entering every counter sale in the system at the time of sale, including cash sales with no customer name, would stop this from recurring.
The grade
Graded 2026-11-11 00:29 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.2, the model that made the attempt.
| Criterion | Result | Note |
|---|---|---|
| r1 | pass | Both differences found (4103 and 4111) and the margin question on 4105 addressed. |
| r2 | pass | 4103 resolved by invoice 2291 and the Sep 24 deposit; 4111 by the Sep 29 deposit; 4105 by Alder's account. |
| r3 | pass | Corrected total $3,960.00, tied to the deposits day by day, with both record totals reconciled to it. |
| r4 | pass | Neither record changed; three corrections recommended for the owner's approval. |
| r5 | pass | Every sum, total and difference checks. |
| r6 | fail (minor) | The differences are set out one by one but not in a table, and the note runs to about 520 words, not a few sentences. Fix: put the differing lines in a table and cut the prose. |
Overall: passes with named fixes. The reconciliation is right throughout. The one shortfall is form: no table of the differing lines and a note longer than the rubric asks.
Earlier attempts
Claude Fable 5.1, 2026-10-01 03:41 UTC: passes
The attempt, one pass, unedited
Claude Fable 5.1, written 2026-10-01 03:41 UTC from the brief and the material only.
NOTE TO THE OWNER: cash receipts, week of September 22 to 26 I compared the system printout with the counter journal receipt by receipt. Eight of the ten numbered receipts agree exactly. The differences: | Receipt | System | Journal | What the other records show | Which is right | |---|---|---|---|---| | 4103, Sep 23, Brightwater Builders | $1,260.00 | $1,620.00 | Invoice 2291, Sep 23, $1,260.00, marked paid. The Sep 24 deposit of $1,380.00 equals 4103 plus 4104 only if 4103 is $1,260.00 ($1,260.00 + $120.00). | The system. The journal transposed the digits, 1,620 for 1,260. | | 4105, Sep 24, Alder Landscaping | $340.00 | $340.00, margin note "same as Mon? check" | Alder's account shows two separate rentals, Sep 22 and Sep 24, $340.00 each. The Sep 25 deposit of $915.00 equals 4105 plus 4106 ($340.00 + $575.00). | Both. A real second rental, not a duplicate; the margin question can be cleared. | | 4111, Sep 26, cash sale, no name | not in the system | $30.00 | The Sep 29 deposit of $285.00 equals 4109 plus 4110 plus 4111 ($210.00 + $45.00 + $30.00). | The journal. The $30.00 sale was taken in and banked but never entered in the system. | Corrected weekly total: $3,960.00. Check against the bank: deposits of $425.00 + $1,380.00 + $915.00 + $955.00 + $285.00 = $3,960.00, and each day's deposit matches that day's receipts (Sep 22: $340.00 + $85.00 = $425.00; Sep 23: $1,260.00 + $120.00 = $1,380.00; Sep 24: $340.00 + $575.00 = $915.00; Sep 25: $65.00 + $890.00 = $955.00; Sep 26: $210.00 + $45.00 + $30.00 = $285.00). Why the two records disagree with it: the printout's $3,930.00 is short the $30.00 receipt 4111; the journal's $4,320.00 is $360.00 high from the transposition on 4103 ($1,620.00 less $1,260.00). Recommended corrections, for your approval; I have not changed either record: 1. Enter receipt 4111, Sep 26, cash sale, $30.00, in the system. 2. Correct the journal line for 4103 to $1,260.00 and initial the change. 3. Clear the margin note on 4105: second rental, confirmed against the account. After these, both records total $3,960.00 and agree with the bank.
The grade
Graded 2026-10-01 03:44 UTC against the rubric above, by Claude Fable 5.1, the model that made the attempt.
| Criterion | Result | Note |
|---|---|---|
| r1 | pass | 4103, 4111 and the 4105 margin question, all found. |
| r2 | pass | Each resolved with the invoice, the account and the matching daily deposit. |
| r3 | pass | $3,960.00, tied to the bank day by day; the $30.00 shortfall and the $360.00 transposition explained. |
| r4 | pass | Three recommendations for approval; neither record altered. |
| r5 | pass | Every sum re-added without error. |
| r6 | pass | A three-row table and a short note. |
Overall: passes. The reconciliation uses the deposits as the tie-breaker day by day, which is the strongest evidence available, and keeps the owner in charge of the corrections.
How the examples are made and graded: the method. Every task of this job, with its length and when it comes within reach: Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks.